The idea of telling the story of the Armenian genocide – or, really, any other genocide – and repeating those stories is really important. I also think it’s important to always be exposing the warning signs for what was leading up to it. Those tend to always be the same.
–Chris Cornell, lead singer, Soungarden, Audioslave
The International Court of Justice (ICJ) set an historic precedent yesterday by ruling that Myanmar was guilty of committing genocide against the Rohingya during its 2017 military operations in the West Coast Rakhine State.
It was the first time a state was held directly responsible under the 1948 Geneva Convention for genocide since Serbia was held responsible for failing to prevent genocide in 2007 for the 1995 Srebrenica genocide against Bosnian Muslims. While Serbia was not held directly liable for genocide, it was found guilty of violating its duty to punish perpetrators identified at the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY), such as Ratko Mladić. Serbia was also found guilty of breaching the ICJ provisional measures requested by Yugoslavia (Serbia and Montenegro) and granted in April 1993 and reaffirmed in September 1993.
In the Bosnian genocide case, the ICJ ordered the transfer of those charged with war crimes to the ICTY for prosecution, but rejected financial compensation to the Bosnians or fines to Yugoslavia (Serbia and Montenegro). Meanwhile, in the Rohingya case, the ICJ ordered that Myanmar investigate and prosecute all those responsible, implement legislative changes to guarantee that genocide is not repeated, facilitate the safe return of displaced victims, restore property, and provide full compensation.
The ICJ had also dismissed claims brought against each other in 2015 by both Serbia and Croatia due to a failure to prove genocidal intent (dolus specialis), which is a core legal element under the Genocide Convention.
It must be remembered that the ICJ does not prosecute anyone accused of committing genocide. It settles legal disputes between states brought before it, whereas criminal prosecution of individuals for genocide is the responsibility of the International Criminal Court (ICC) or specialised tribunals set up by the United Nations. While the government of Bosnia and Herzegovina referred its own case to the ICJ, the Myanmar genocide was brought before the court by The Gambia in 2019 and was supported by the 57 member states of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC).
The ICJ’s ordering of provisional measures (both temporary and urgent) and final measures or remedies in cases brought before it is both legally binding and highly significant, as I will show later. Yesterday’s final ruling by the ICJ against Myanmar included a finding that the interim measures the court ordered in 2020 had been breached. These interim measures were (a) to prevent acts of genocide, (b) to restrain its military and armed forces, (c) to preserve evidence, and (d) to report compliance to the court.
There are currently two other cases before the ICJ under the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide where provisional measures have been ordered:
- Ukraine vs. Russian Federation: filed by the Ukrainian government in 2022 over Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
- South Africa vs. Israel: filed by the government of South Africa in 2023 against Israel over its military conduct against Palestinians in Gaza. Here, the Court ordered further interim measures in March and May 2024 to supplement those of January 2024.
There are two other cases pending before the ICJ where provisional measures have either not been ordered or have been declined:
- Nicaragua vs. Germany: filed by the Nicaraguan government in 2024 and concerns breaches of international humanitarian law and obligations through its military, financial, and political support for Israel in its military campaign in Gaza, and also the suspension of funding for the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees (UNRWA). The court declined to grant provisional measures.
- Democratic Republic of the Congo v. Rwanda: filed by the DRC government in 2026 as a result of international human rights violations from armed conflicts and atrocities since 1996. Earlier cases brought by the DRC in 1999 and 2002 were rejected because the ICJ ruled that it lacked jurisdiction.
As a South African, the case my government brought before the ICJ against Israel is of particular interest to me personally, not that the other cases are any less important. This is the first case of genocide brought against a state that is arguably part of the Western world. Even though Israel is geographically located in the Middle East, it has very strong political, economic and cultural ties with the West. Given that its ties with Europe and the U.S., in particular, are key to its existential survival, it is hard to argue that it is not an outpost of the West.
There now exist widespread (well-reasoned) allegations that Israel’s origins are illegal and settler colonial in nature and that Zionism is closely linked to Jewish Nationalism and supremacy. Its claim of historical and divine rights to the land is spurious at best. It would be very interesting and highly suspicious if the ICJ dismissed the genocide case against it.
Even though Israel has a friendly insider who also happens to be the Vice-President of the court, sitting on the ICJ’s judicial panel, in Uganda’s Julia Sebutinde, it is not enough to rescue it from the inevitable. Sebutinde was one of the dissenting judges in the Myanmar case.
I have absolutely no doubt that Israel is guilty of genocide. I am far from alone in this regard. Here is a list of those who are as convinced as I am:
- The United Nations Commission of Inquiry.
- A multitude of human rights organisations, including Amnesty International and Israel’s own B’Tselem.
- Academic & genocide-prevention groups such as the International Association of Genocide Scholars, the Lemkin Institute for Genocide Prevention, Jewish Voice for Peace and Genocide Watch. (A comprehensive list is available at the link above).
- Legal experts and scholars
- The United Nations Special Rapporteur on the occupied Palestinian territories, Francesca Albanese.
Since the ICJ’s finding that there was a plausible risk of Israel committing genocide in January 2024, it ordered them to implement various provisional measures:
- prevent and punish genocidal acts
- block public incitement
- facilitate basic humanitarian aid in Gaza
- preserve evidence of violations
- report back within a month
All except the last were violated with impunity. The court ordered further measures in March 2024 as the humanitarian crisis deepened in Gaza:
- To ensure the large-scale delivery of basic services and supplies.
- To expand and keep land crossings open.
- To refrain from military actions violating protected rights.
- To submit a compliance report within a month.
Following the calamitous Israeli military ground offensive in Rafah, which had become the last refuge for over a million fleeing Palestinians, the ICJ ordered further measures in May 2024:
- Immediately halt its military offensive or any actions in the Rafah Governorate that risk physical destruction in Gaza.
- To keep the Rafah crossing open for aid.
- To ensure unimpeded access for UN-mandated investigative bodies.
- To report within a month.
While Israel did submit a report back to the ICJ in April 2024, there have still been widespread violations of every single provisional order. It’s hard to imagine the situation getting worse for the Palestinians, but it did.
As with the Myanmar and Russia cases, the ICJ’s provisional measures provided no protection for the victims of genocide. The United Nations is evidently paralysed or impotent to enforce the ICJ’s provisional orders, especially since the U.S. exerts so much negative political influence there through its veto power, but also through its political and military support for Israel.
The evidence for Israel committing genocide is mounting. This instance is being described as the most documented, live-streamed, watched, commented on, and supported in history. Israel meets every single criterion for being found guilty. As the Myanmar ruling proves, the number of victims is irrelevant to the determination of guilt. There is also ample evidence of intent, as both Israeli citizens, the soldiers, media pundits, and government members seem to have few qualms about publicly sharing their hatred and inhumanity.
Currently, as I write, Israel is openly violating the Gaza ceasefire initiated in October 2025. The Nasser Hospital has been bombed yet again, killing six people, including surgeon Dr Rizk Abu Shaira and a 13-year-old boy. Elsewhere, around 350 000 Palestinians living in tents are affected by extensive flooding. Meanwhile, aid organisations indicate that the Israeli authorities are refusing to deliver tents inside Gaza.
It’s as if conducting a genocide isn’t enough…
The only reason it would take time to reach a verdict is the mountain of evidence the judges would have to sift through. The actual eventual ruling and vote should, I think, be a mere formality.







Please leave a comment or reply